I’ve executed some analysis throughout the Web and gathered an inventory of Professionals and Cons concerning the “Money For Clunkers” program. I made an inventory for the person who’s contemplating shopping for a automotive by way of this system, and in addition an inventory for the “Collective Soul”, for us to contemplate the general affect within the universe, as described on this article.

To date the Professionals and Cons add as much as this: Particular person: Four-Professional, 6-Con. Collective Soul: 6-Professional, 12-Con.



1. $Four,500 + different incentives you could possibly save some huge cash on a brand new automotive buy, in the event you push for extra incentives moreover simply the $Four,500.

2. Much less Gasoline. You possibly can save some huge cash on the pump.

three. Lower down on restore prices.

Four. Surroundings – your driving will trigger much less air pollution.


1. Insurance coverage – it often prices extra to insure a brand new automotive.

2. New Debt – it’s smart to enter extra debt in your monetary state of affairs?

three. Wasted components – your outdated automotive shall be destroyed. It is questionable whether or not or not a number of the components shall be recycled.

Four. Worth added to your outdated clunker. The used automotive market might warmth up as a result of decreased provide. It is doable that your used automotive could also be value greater than the voucher after the trickle-down of this Money for Clunkers program.

5. Extra gasoline. You could be inclined to drive extra understanding that your automotive will get higher gasoline mileage.

6. Consolation Zone. You KNOW your outdated automotive. And you understand what repairs you’ve got executed to it and what’s more likely to go mistaken.



1. Will increase gross sales at auto sellers.

2. Surge in new-car gross sales to shoppers who wouldn’t in any other case buy presently. For the higher and center revenue folks with adequate credit score to get a automotive mortgage, offers them a down cost.

three. Previous automobiles are sometimes much less fuel-efficient than their trendy counterparts, so eradicating them from the street and changing them with newer automobiles would probably lower particular person house owners’ and the nation’s consumption of oil.

Four. Previous automobiles sometimes don’t run as clear as new automobiles, so eradicating and changing them on our roads would probably lower automobile exhaust emissions, lessening the affect on the atmosphere.

5. Previous automobiles weren’t held to the identical crash and security requirements as new automobiles are held to and are usually much less protected in an accident. Changing them with newer automobiles may result in fewer accidents and fatalities in car accidents.

6. Automakers are struggling proper now, particularly home automakers. Offering a monetary incentive to purchase new automobiles would probably result in elevated automotive gross sales, which might generate income for the automakers and assist them climate the financial downturn, whereas stimulating the financial system on the identical time.


1. Synthetic, unsustainable increase in auto gross sales.

2. Crushing these older working autos makes these components and automobiles more durable to get, and consequently costlier.

three. Many firms construct components and upgrades for older automobiles. A decreased provide of older automobiles would adversely have an effect on their gross sales.

Four. The automotive restoration and customization business depends on outdated automobiles as the premise of their merchandise. A decreased provide of older automobiles would adversely have an effect on their gross sales.

5. For decrease revenue folks, makes it more durable to seek out and keep an older automobile.

6. Convincing low revenue folks, those that drive “clunkers”, to exit and finance a brand new automotive after we are nonetheless within the midst of the results of straightforward credit score within the housing market.

7. Drop in automobile donations to charities. Some charities that depend on automobile donations for funding say they’re receiving fewer automobiles and vans, as a result of donors change their minds and resolve to commerce the automobiles in on the Money for Clunkers program.

eight. Some older automobiles truly get higher gasoline mileage than some newer ones. Changing them would then negate any profit to the atmosphere or the U.S.’ oil consumption downside.

9. Encouraging shoppers to scrap working automobiles may shorten the lives of automobiles and encourage the manufacturing of latest automobiles, which might have a bigger antagonistic have an effect on on the atmosphere that protecting the older automotive.

10. This proposal wouldn’t essentially profit the automakers which can be within the worst monetary form, as there isn’t a assure that buyers would use their incentive to buy a automobile from a kind of producers and never one other firm.

11. This system isn’t restricted to AMERICANS, and never restricted to AMERICAN made automobiles, however it’s coming from AMERICAN taxpayer cash.

12. It’s costing greater than $Four,500 per trade-in. It’s costing roughly $6,000 per automobile, when factoring in the price of the additional authorities staffing, workplace area lease, gear, staff, net growth, printing of kinds, and so on.


Leave a Reply